Retirement is a great time to simplify the weekly errands, stretch your budget, and bring more convenience to everyday life. Shopping subscriptions can help you do all three—if you choose the plan that matches how you actually shop. In this guide, we compare today’s major options for U.S. shoppers: Amazon Prime, Walmart+, Target Circle 360, Instacart+, and Shipt—including what they cost, what you get, and who each one fits best.
Retirement Hobby Guide participates in various affiliate programs, which means we may earn commissions on products or services that we recommend. These commissions come at no additional cost to you and help support the operation of this site. We only promote products and services that we believe add genuine value to our readers. For more information, please read our full Privacy & Affiliate Disclosure Policy.
Quick Take: Which One Fits Your Life?
- Amazon Prime – Best all-around for online shopping + entertainment, especially if you already watch Prime Video or buy a little of everything online. Amazon
- Walmart+ – Best for groceries + household with local store delivery, plus fuel discounts if you drive regularly. Walmart.com+1
- Target Circle 360 – Best for Target loyalists who want unlimited same-day delivery (via Shipt) and fast shipping on Target.com. Good promos appear during holidays. Target+2Target+2
- Instacart+ – Best for multi-store grocery delivery (including local grocers and Costco) with low minimums on delivery-fee waivers. Instacart+1
- Shipt – Best for those who prefer dedicated shoppers and stores supported by Shipt (Target and many regional grocers). Shipt Help
Price & Key Perks at a Glance (2025)
| Service | Typical Price* | Headline Perks |
|---|---|---|
| Amazon Prime | $14.99/mo or $139/yr; discounted tiers exist (student/Access). | Fast/free shipping on many items, Prime Video (separate options may apply), pharmacy and grocery options vary by area. Amazon |
| Walmart+ | (See site for current pricing) | Free local store delivery on eligible orders, fuel discounts at Exxon/Mobil, Murphy & Sam’s Club stations, in-store Scan & Go. Walmart.com+1 |
| Target Circle 360 | $10.99/mo or $99/yr; promos/discounts appear seasonally. | Unlimited same-day delivery (orders $35+), fast/free shipping on Target.com, access to Shipt marketplace. Target+1 |
| Instacart+ | About $99/yr (or monthly), often with trials. | $0 delivery fees on orders $10+ (varies by store) and partner perks; service fees still apply. Instacart+1 |
| Shipt | $10.99/mo or $99/yr; 14-day trial offered. | $0 delivery fee on $35+ orders at participating stores; ability to favorite shoppers. Shipt Help+1 |
*Prices and benefits change; check each service’s page for the latest in your ZIP code.
Amazon Prime: The Everything Membership
What you get: Fast/free shipping on a huge selection, plus options like Prime Video (plans vary), Rx savings, and occasional partner perks (e.g., food delivery partnerships). Amazon frequently updates what’s included. Household sharing rules have tightened in 2025: free-shipping sharing outside your primary address (old “invitee” program) has ended, and the Amazon Family/Household model focuses on those at the same address. The Verge+3Amazon+3Amazon+3
Why retirees might like it
- One-stop convenience for household staples, hobby supplies, and gifts.
- Broadest product variety; reliable returns process.
- If you already stream with Prime Video or use Kindle benefits, the bundle value improves.
Keep in mind
- Entertainment benefits and shipping rules evolve (and sometimes unbundle).
- Not every item ships free/fast to every ZIP code—always check the product page. Amazon
Best for: All-purpose online shoppers who want fast shipping plus media perks in one bill.
Verdict: If you buy a mix of items year-round, Prime is still the default “do-everything” membership—especially useful for gift seasons and hobby gear. Amazon
Use Retirement Hobby Guide’s link to sign up today
Walmart+: Groceries, Fuel Savings, and Local Store Power
What you get: Local-store delivery for groceries and general merchandise, fuel discounts at Exxon, Mobil, Walmart & Murphy stations (and member pricing at Sam’s Club), plus time-savers like mobile Scan & Go in store. Walmart.com+1
Why retirees might like it
- Groceries to your door from the Walmart you already use—fresh food, pharmacy items, and household goods in one drop.
- Fuel savings can add up if you drive regularly to hobbies, family, or appointments.
- Early access to some deals can help with big-ticket buys (TVs, garden equipment).
Keep in mind
- Delivery minimums and item eligibility vary by location.
- If you rarely shop Walmart or drive infrequently, fuel perks matter less. Walmart.com
Best for: Shoppers who already rely on Walmart and want groceries/household delivered weekly, plus gas savings.
Verdict: A strong value if Walmart is your primary store and you’ll actually use delivery and fuel perks. Walmart.com+1
Target Circle 360: Same-Day Delivery for Target Loyalists
What you get: Unlimited same-day delivery on $35+ orders, fast/free shipping on many Target.com items, and access to the Shipt marketplace for partner stores. Target often runs promos (e.g., seasonal rewards or discounts on the annual plan, plus extra savings if you use the Target Circle Card). Target+2Target+2
Why retirees might like it
- Friendly in-store brands (Good & Gather, Up&Up) delivered to your door.
- Same-day delivery is excellent for household restocks and last-minute items.
- Periodic membership promos can lower your annual cost.
Keep in mind
- The biggest savings happen if you primarily shop Target.
- Same-day delivery has a $35+ order expectation for unlimited use. Target
Best for: Target fans who love the brand’s quality and want fast delivery without leaving home.
Verdict: If Target is “your store,” Circle 360 is a smooth, senior-friendly way to keep essentials coming without the trip. Target
Instacart+: The Most Flexible Grocery Network
What you get: Membership benefits that typically include $0 delivery fees on orders of $10+ (store-dependent), plus access to dozens of regional grocers and retailers (including Costco in many areas) from one app. Service fees still apply. Instacart has emphasized lower minimums and wider coverage in the last year. Instacart+2Investopedia+2
Why retirees might like it
- Shop your favorite local stores (and specialty grocers) without driving.
- The lower $10+ threshold on many orders makes it useful for smaller, top-off trips—milk, fruit, a missing spice—rather than waiting to hit $35–$50. Investopedia
- Seasonal deals and retailer promos can offset some fees.
Keep in mind
- Delivery fee may be $0, but service fees often still apply; tip your shopper.
- Selection and pricing depend on the store; not every ZIP code has the same roster. Instacart
Best for: Those who like choice—different grocers, pharmacies, and big-box stores—and who value small, frequent orders.
Verdict: Excellent for flexibility and smaller shops; read the fine print on service fees so you know your true cost. Instacart
Shipt: Friendly Shoppers and Store-By-Store Loyalty
What you get: Membership with $0 delivery fees on $35+ orders at participating stores, the ability to favorite shoppers for consistency, and frequent membership promotions. Shipt powers Target’s same-day delivery and also partners with many regional grocers. Shipt Help+1
Why retirees might like it
- The “preferred shopper” feature adds a human touch—repeat shoppers learn your preferences (green bananas? low-sodium options?).
- Works well if your favorite local grocer is on Shipt.
Keep in mind
- Under $35, delivery usually adds a fee; availability varies by ZIP code. Shipt Help
- Selection depends on Shipt’s store network where you live.
Best for: Shoppers who value personal, consistent service from the same shopper and frequently buy $35+ baskets.
Verdict: Personal and dependable, especially in markets with strong Shipt coverage (and if Target is a core store). Shipt Help
How to Choose: 5 Simple Questions
- Where do you already shop most?
Match the membership to your main store (Walmart+ for Walmart, Circle 360 for Target). If you shop everywhere, Prime or Instacart+ may fit better. Instacart+3Walmart.com+3Target+3 - Do you need fast shipping beyond groceries?
Prime shines for broad online orders; Target Circle 360 adds fast shipping on Target.com. Amazon+1 - Will you use grocery delivery weekly?
Walmart+, Target Circle 360, Shipt, and Instacart+ all deliver groceries—compare order minimums and fees for your ZIP code. Instacart+3Walmart.com+3Target+3 - Do fuel discounts matter to you?
Walmart+ can shave cents off each gallon at partner stations—valuable if you drive often. Variety - Do you place small, frequent orders?
Instacart+ is attractive with its lower $10+ threshold for $0 delivery fee at many stores (service fees apply). Investopedia
Sample Scenarios (Pick Your Match)
- “We cook most meals at home and want groceries delivered weekly.”
Choose Walmart+ (if Walmart is your main store) or Target Circle 360 (if you prefer Target’s selection). If you rotate between multiple grocers, Instacart+ offers the most flexibility. Walmart.com+2Target+2 - “We buy a little of everything online—books, hobby tools, household—and we stream shows.”
Amazon Prime gives the widest online selection plus entertainment. Amazon - “We make small top-off trips (bread, milk, fruit) several times a week.”
Instacart+ can waive delivery fees at lower order minimums (read service-fee details). Investopedia - “We love working with the same shopper who knows our preferences.”
Shipt lets you favorite shoppers for more consistent experiences. Shipt Grocery Delivery
Tips to Maximize Value (and Avoid Surprises)
- Stack store cards and promos.
Target Circle Card holders sometimes see extra perks (and occasional Circle 360 discounts). Watch for holiday events. Target+1 - Know the difference between “$0 delivery fee” and “service fees.”
Many memberships waive delivery fees but still charge service fees; tips are separate and go to your shopper. Instacart+1 - Check ZIP-code availability.
Delivery speed, eligible items, and store partners vary by location for every service. Always verify on the official page. Amazon+2Walmart.com+2 - Share carefully.
Amazon has tightened sharing of Prime free-shipping to the same household in 2025; plan memberships accordingly. AP News+1
Bottom Line: Our Plain-English Recommendations
- Choose Amazon Prime if you want broad online shopping and like the bundle of shipping + entertainment. It’s the best “default” if you shop for a bit of everything. Amazon
- Choose Walmart+ if you want weekly grocery delivery + fuel savings and already shop Walmart. The gas perk can clinch it for drivers. Walmart.com+1
- Choose Target Circle 360 if you’re a Target loyalist who values fast shipping and same-day delivery on Target’s brands and partners. Target
- Choose Instacart+ if you want maximum store choice and smaller, frequent orders with a lower delivery-fee threshold (watch service fees). Investopedia
- Choose Shipt if you value a personal shopper relationship and your favorite stores are on its network (Target, many regionals). Shipt Help
Gentle Next Steps
- Pick the one that matches how you already shop.
- Start with a monthly plan or free trial to test real-life value in your ZIP code. Shipt Help
- Set a reminder for 3 weeks to decide: keep it, switch, or cancel.
Leave a Reply